Most of us can rattle off the health rules without blinking. Eat the vegetables at peak ripeness. Hit the step count. Get the sleep number. Drink the water. What almost nobody can answer, if you stop and ask them directly, is why they're doing any of it.

In this episode, Elizabeth Sherman steps back from her own morning walk on the beach in Mexico, and her Apple Watch nagging her to pick up the pace, to ask a bigger question: what is your health actually supposed to give you? Not the version you're supposed to want. The real one, underneath the vegetables and the step count.

Free quiz: Still saying 'I know what to do, I just don't do it'? Take the free quiz and find out which pattern is running the show.

She also shares something that happened to her recently at the doctor's office that had nothing to do with how she looks and everything to do with what her body can still do for her twenty years from now. It's the kind of finding that doesn't show up in the mirror, and it reframes the whole conversation about what appearance can and can't tell you about health.

This is not a checklist episode. It's an invitation to ask yourself a question most of us have never actually sat with.

The Listener Takeaway: Why This Episode Matters

If you've ever felt like you're doing all the things and still can't say why, this episode gives you permission to stop collecting more rules and start asking a different question. Once you know what your health is actually for, whether that's a hug that doesn't feel careful, a work meeting you're fully present for, or a trip you're still physically able to take at seventy, the daily grind of "shoulds" starts to loosen its grip.

You don't walk away with a new plan. You walk away with a reason that's actually yours, which is the thing every plan has been missing.


Are you loving the podcast, but arent sure where to start? click here to get your copy of the Done with Dieting Podcast Roadmap (formerly Total Health in Midlife) Its a fantastic listining guide that pulls out the exact episodes that will get you moving towards optimal health.


Take the Quiz: Why Do Your Healthy Habits Keep Falling Apart? If you've ever wondered why you know exactly what to do but still can't seem to stick with it, this quiz was built for you. In about 3 minutes, it identifies your specific pattern: the real reason your follow-through keeps breaking down, and what to address first. Your results are delivered straight to your inbox.


I am so excited to hear what you all think about the podcast – if you have any feedback, please let me know! You can leave me a rating and review in Apple Podcasts, which helps me create an excellent show and helps other women who want to get off the diet roller coaster find it, too.


Watch or Listen to the Episode:



WHAT YOU'LL LEARN

  • What actually happens when you keep asking yourself why, past the first answer you give
  • Why doing everything "right" on the outside doesn't guarantee what's happening on the inside, including what a recent doctor's visit taught Elizabeth about her own bones
  • The real difference between wanting more years and wanting more years you can actually use
  • Why appearance can't tell you the one thing that actually matters about your health

RESOURCES

  • Free 30-Minute Health Diagnostic Session (elizabethsherman.com/diagnostic)
  • Episode 178: What's it Mean to Achieve Optimal Health? — If "optimal health" is a phrase that's never actually been defined for you, this episode goes deeper into what it means and why it looks different for every woman.
  • Episode 190: Breaking the Midlife Exercise Myths — For more on why bone density and strength matter more than the scale, this episode breaks down what's actually protecting your independence later in life.

Full Episode Transcript:

297 - What does it mean to HEALTH?

297 - What does it mean to HEALTH?

Elizabeth: [00:00:00] So if you've been listening to my other recent podcast episodes, I recently sat down with a new doctor, got a full workup done, and found out some things about my own health and my body that had nothing to do with how I look in the mirror, something I couldn't have caught by looking in a mirror at all, getting my yearly Pap smear or mammogram even.

So many of us are focused on the wrong thing when it comes to our health, and not that Pap smears and mammograms are wrong, but I digress. We are managing our weight, our steps, our clothing size, our calories, and never actually asking the one question underneath all of it: Why are we doing this?

What is this actually all for? If you've never sat down and answered that question for yourself, today's episode might change how you think about every health choice that you make from here on out. So stick around. This one is worth the whole [00:01:00] listen

Welcome to the Done With Dieting Total Health for Women Over 40 podcast, the podcast for women who are done with the start over cycle and ready for a way of taking care of themselves that actually works.

hey, everyone. Welcome back to the Done with Dieting podcast, the podcast for total health for women over 40. I am Elizabeth Sherman, and thank you so much for tuning in today. I am super glad that you're here with me. Now, I wanna start out with a story, because most mornings, I take my dog, Coco, down to the beach here in Mexico.

We live about a block away. Same time, same stretch of sand, same warm air coming off the water, and almost every single time, my Apple Watch tells me that I need to pick up the pace, and I don't pay that much attention to it, and not because I don't care about my health, but because I have started asking a question that [00:02:00] I never used to ask before.

Picking up the pace for what exactly? Where am I trying to get to that's better than right here, watching my dog chase a wave, chase the ball, just creating so much joy for myself and for the other beachgoers. Now, I see a lot of tourists on that same stretch of beach, especially during the high season when it's a little busier in town.

They're power walking, their arms are pumping, their eyes are on their watch, their heart rate is climbing on purpose. And I get it. I used to be someone exactly like that. I needed to get my cardio on. But I watch them go by now, and I think, "You know, you're on vacation in one of the most beautiful places on Earth, and you are missing most of it because you're so focused on getting your sweat on."

That's less a [00:03:00] story about walking and more a story about how most of us have been taught to think about our health in general. If you're anything like the women that I work with, you already know all the rules. You eat your vegetables, you get your 10,000 steps in, you walk with a weighted vest strapped on maybe, you hit your protein number, your sleep number, your step number, your everything number.

There's always another number that you need to meet. And here's what I notice with almost every client who sits down in front of me for the first time. She's doing a lot of the right things, or at least trying to, and she really can't tell you why we're doing these things. She says that she should be doing it, that that's what they tell us that we should be doing.

She says she's knows what she's supposed to do. But if I stop and ask her what [00:04:00] she actually wants her health to give her underneath all of the shoulds, sometimes it quietly stumps her. And that's the question that I want you to sit with today. Not another list of things to do, not another number to hit, but what is your health actually for?

I know it sounds like a strange question. What is it supposed to be giving you once you get past everything that you think you're supposed to want? We know that we're supposed to have good numbers, right? We know that we're supposed to have low cholesterol and, you know, low blood pressure. But why? Why do we want these things?

Because I think that question changes everything else. And I think that most of us have never actually asked the question of ourselves. Because when we do the things without meaning, they lose their [00:05:00] impact.

And so women have been handed rules since we were kids. These are not fun rules, right? The kind that come with an unspoken deal attached. Good girls follow the rules. And when you're handed that many rules that early, you don't stop and ask where they came from, because that would be overwhelming. You don't have time to ask. There are just so many rules that we have to abide by. Eat this way. Look that way. Stand like this. Take up this much space and not one inch more. Be pleasant about it while you're doing it.

It's a lot easier to just go along with it all than to ask questions and risk getting labeled as the difficult one, right? The one who pushes back. The woman who makes people uncomfortable when she doesn't just go along. So we don't question the rules. We just add another one to the top of the pile. We [00:06:00] just try to get better at following them, and I think that's exactly what has happened with health.

Somewhere along the way, health became one more set of rules that were handed to us, that we decided that we needed to abide by. Eat this, not that. Move this way, not that way. Hit this number. And most of us just started following along the same way that we've been following along ever since we were kids, without ever asking where any of it came from or whether it was actually built for us So let's say that you wanna lose weight, you wanna feel better in your clothes, you wanna get more energy so that you're not dragging by 3:00 in the afternoon.

Like, those are real wants. I'm not gonna sit here and tell you that they don't matter, because they absolutely do. Feeling good in your clothes absolutely matters. Having energy for your [00:07:00] actual life actually matters. I want those things for you, too. But if I keep asking why, if we push past that first answer, most of the time we land on some version of, "So I can live longer."

And there's something real in that as well. None of us wants to get to the end and realize that there was something that we still wanted to do, and we're not capable of doing it, that we didn't accomplish something. Nobody wants unfinished business on their deathbed. But let's actually sit with that for a second.

Living longer. Do you want to live to be 150? Because if someone offered you that today, most of us would probably say, "No, thank you. Not like this." Not if it means another 80 years of the same tired, achy, shut-down feeling a lot of us are already dealing with in our 40s and [00:08:00] 50s. Nobody actually wants more years.

What we want is more years that are actually achievable, that are actually fruitful, that we can use. So if it's not really about the number of years, then what is it about? Now, I think it might be freedom. Your health is what gives you the freedom to actually live the life that you want for as long as you get it.

Not just more years added on to the end, but more years of living the way that you actually want to live, doing the things that matter to you So what does that mean, freedom? What does freedom actually look like, not someday, but this week? I think it's gonna be different depending on what's important to you.

It might look like being able to actually hug the people that you love, and not in a stiff, [00:09:00] careful hug where you hold your belly in or part of you is thinking about your body while you're doing it, but like a real bear hug, loving hug, arms all the way around someone, holding on for a second longer instead of holding yourself back.

It looks like walking into a room and being present in it, not running that quick mental checklist on how you look first, whether your clothes are sitting right, whether anyone's noticing something that you would rather they didn't. Now, I see this with so many of the women that I work with. You walk into a work meeting, and half of your brain is still back in the dressing room from this morning, still thinking about how your blazer doesn't quite button the way that it used to.

You're technically in the room, but your brain isn't there. You can't give the meeting your full attention and presence [00:10:00] because part of you is busy managing how you're coming across, what you look like to everyone else. And I... You know, this is not vanity. That's your attention going to the wrong place.

When your health is working for you, all of that noise just goes away. You walk in, and you're just there. You're focused on the actual conversation, the actual person in front of you, and the actual moment, and you're not managing yourself from the outside while you're supposed to be living the life from inside.

That's what freedom gives you right now today, not someday when you retire. Today, in the meeting, in the hug, in the moment that you would otherwise spend managing how you look instead of just savoring it and being in it Now, freedom isn't just about today, though.

It's about the future, the years that you haven't [00:11:00] gotten to yet, maybe the goals that you have in front of you. Think about what you actually picture when you imagine retirement. Not the version that other people picture for you, but your version. Nobody dreams about spending their retirement in doctor's offices.

Nobody's fantasy involves managing insurance paperwork or keeping track of which pill gets taken at which hour. That's not what any of us are working towards. What we actually picture are things like living freely, dancing, playing pickleball with friends on a weekday morning because you can, walking the cobblestone streets in Italy or Greece without watching every step and having to be careful because your knees can't handle the uneven ground.

I want to hike to Machu Picchu myself one day. That is genuinely on my list. But here's the thing nobody tells you: 65 doesn't hand you that body for [00:12:00] free. If you're not building it right now in your 40s and 50s, it isn't gonna show up for you on its own the year that you automatically retire.

The dancing, the pickleball, the cobblestone streets, the mountain that you want to hike, all of it gets decided before you actually get there, and not by luck, by what you did with your body Long before you needed it to hold up.

So when I ask you what your health is giving you, this is part of the answer as well. Today's freedom and whether the latter versions of your life, the one where you're already picturing for your retirement, is still there waiting for you when you arrive. Now, we've been raised in a society that rewards attractiveness.

That's just true, and there's a whole industry built around convincing you that if you look a certain way, that you've made it. Thinness gets praised. Visible muscle gets praised. [00:13:00] And somewhere along the way, we started treating looking healthy and being healthy as the same thing.

Someone's lean or she's got visible muscle definition, and we assume that that means her insides are in order, too, that her blood work is fine, that her bones are strong, that everything under the surface is running the way that it should because, well, look at her. But that's not actually how any of this works.

You can look exactly the way our culture tells you that a healthy person is supposed to look and still have something going on underneath that nobody, including you, can see from the outside. And it runs the other way, too.

A woman can carry more weight, and we assume the opposite. We assume something's wrong, something is failing that we can point to, and that's not true either. Body size on its own doesn't tell you a single [00:14:00] thing about what's happening on the inside of someone. I'll tell you how I know this personally. I recently went to a new doctor for a full workup, including blood work and a bone density scan, and it turns out I am in the early stages of osteopenia.

Now, my bones are starting to lose density earlier than I would have expected. And from the outside, I do all the right things. I move my body, I eat well, and I have built a whole career around health. If you were just looking at me and looking at my logs and all of the stuff, the data, you would have no reason to think that anything was off, and that's kind of my point.

Appearance tells us nothing. The only reason I know is because I actually got a bone density scan. If I had let that keep going without doing anything about it, it wouldn't have [00:15:00] shown up on my face or in my clothes. It would probably have shown up much later when I broke a bone or in a body that couldn't do the things that I've been telling you today that I want mine to keep doing.

That's the thing about appearance. It leaves out the one part that actually matters. If you wanna go deeper on what optimal health really means and why that phrase means something different for every single woman, I've got a whole episode on it, episode 178. Go find it after this one if you wanna dig into it.

But for right now, just sit with this idea. What your body looks like and what your body can actually do for you are two different questions, and only one of them tells you the truth Now, this is the only body that you get. It's not a practice round or a draft that you get [00:16:00] to revise later.

This is the one that has to carry you through everything else in your life. So the question isn't really, am I doing health right? That question is much bigger than that. How does your health let you actually be your authentic self, the way that you wanna show up in the world? How does it let you celebrate, like really celebrate, the things in your life that are worth celebrating?

How does it let you love the people that you love and care for them the way that you actually want to? How does it let you sit with someone in grief, carry your own sadness without it flattening you, stay connected instead of checking out, and be part of the shared experience of being human with the other people around you?

That's what your health is actually for. It's not the number on the scale. It's not the steps or the [00:17:00] vegetables or the watch buzzing at you to go faster. All of that is in service of something much bigger, your actual life and every part of what it means to be human in it. I'm not gonna hand you a checklist at, to figure this out today.

I don't think this question, this topic, works that way. I just want you to sit with the question. What is the bigger picture for you? Because once you actually know that, once you actually have your own answer instead of someone else's, everything shifts. All that knowing what to do but not doing it starts to loosen.

You actually have a reason that's actually yours. Now, if everything I just said is landing and you're already thinking about your own answer to that question, I wanna invite you to take it one step further. Now, I offer a free 30-minute diagnostic [00:18:00] call, just you and me, one-on-one, a real conversation rather than a sales pitch or another plan handed to you that's generic.

We look at what's actually getting in the way of your health, specifically yours, not some generic version of it. Because knowing your bigger why is one thing, actually living it inside your real week with your real schedule and your real life and your real constraints, that is a totally different thing, and that's what this call is for.

You can find it at elizabethsherman.com/diagnostic, and I'll put that link in the show notes, too. So book a time and we'll talk, and you'll walk away with real clarity whether or not we end up working together after that. So thank you so much for spending this time with me today. I will see you in the next episode.

Have an amazing day. I'll talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Hey, thanks for tuning in today. If what we talked about is landing and you're ready to figure out [00:19:00] what's actually getting in your way, I would love to invite you to a free diagnostic session with me. It's 30 minutes long, just us, looking at where your specific weight keeps breaking down and where you need support applying what you already know.

You'll leave with a clear picture of what's driving it and what would actually help next. No shame, no macros, no pretending you have infinite capacity, and certainly no lecture about trying harder. Go to elizabethsherman.com/diagnostic to grab your time. I would love to see you on the call


Enjoy the Show?

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is apple_podcast_button.png
This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is spotify.png